Tuesday, October 13, 2009

French Keynesians Or Why The US Fights The Secular Force

This is a topic I wanted to write already months ago. Last time I touched this issue was, I suppose, this one in August.

Now I have got the time and an excellent research note from the economists at Societe Generale they wrote back in mid-September. Here is the quote in full:

Higher savings needs higher income and flatter income distribution.

Another secular force that helps to explain long-term movements in savings is the income distribution. Recently, distribution statistics of 2007 income became available, revealing the most skewed income scales in the US since the 1920s, or in some cases even exceeding the 1920s. For example, the top 10% of earners (incomes above $109,630) took in 49.7% of total US income, the highest on record. The top 1% of earners (incomes above $398,909) took in 23.5% of total income, the highest ratio since 1929. These peaks tend to coincide with secular troughs in savings trends.

The peaks in income skewness – 1929 and what is likely to be 2007 – tell us that there is something fundamentally unsustainable about an excessively uneven income distribution. The key lies in the fact that consumption distribution tends to be far more stable. Maintaining steady consumption shares as income shares shift dramatically can only be achieved via expansion of credit from the rich to the poor. This can continue only up to a point, until middle-class incomes can't support any additional debt.

Click on charts to enlarge, courtesy of Societe Generale.

Cross-sectional data also supports a strong relationship between savings and income distribution. France, with one of the flattest income distributions in the western world happens to have one of the least-leveraged household sectors.

The other side of the story is that the top earners in periods of uneven income distribution have tended to invest their excess savings in very inefficient ways. For example, in recent years the savers have financed the excess expansion of housing stock via purchases of mortgage bonds and other indirect investments into the financial sector. Had those inefficient investments never been made (or had the savings been channeled into more productive investments), the savings transfer and a build-up of debt would not have gone on as long as it did.

The moral of the story is that at some point an uneven distribution of income becomes unsustainable because there is no-one left to consume. In the end, the market tends to force an adjustment as it did in 1929 and in 2008. Though these adjustment periods are painful for everyone, the wealthy suffer disproportionate income losses. These include not only lower pay, but also capital gains losses which can wipe out accumulated income earned in previous years. When 2008 figures become available, we are likely to see a significant reversal of fortunes.

If historic relationships continue to hold, the anticipated secular rise in the savings rate will likely be accompanied by a flattening income distribution. Whether these will be market-driven or policy driven trends remains to be seen. However, there is little doubt that deleveraging of household balance sheets requires not only higher incomes overall, but in particular for the middle-income households with highest debt burdens.


Correlation does not mean causality? Well, let's put all, including foreign, resources to fight the secular forces of "Mother Nature"?

Monday, October 12, 2009

Fed Praying The Reflation Trade Is Not Slipping Out Of Hands?

Anonymous commenter reminded me about the reflation in the context of Fisher's Debt Deflation over the weekend. Irving Fisher wrote:
Assuming, accordingly, that at some point of time, a state of over-indebtedness exists, this will tend to lead to liquidation, through the alarm either of debtors or creditors or both. Then we may deduce the following chain of consequences in nine links: (1) debt liquidation leads to distress selling and to (2) Contraction of deposit currency, as bank loans are paid off, and to a slowing down of velocity of circulation. This contraction of deposits and of their velocity, precipitated by distress selling, causes (3) a fall in the level of prices, in other words, a swelling of the dollar. Assuming, as above stated, that this fall of prices is not interfered with by reflation or otherwise, there must be (4) a still greater fall in the net worth of business, precipitating bankruptcies and (5) a like fall in profits, which in a "capitalistic", that is, a private-profit society, leads the concerns which are running at a loss to make (6) a reduction in output, in trade and in employment of labor. These losses, bankruptcies, and unemployment, lead to (7) pessimism and loss of confidence, which in turn lead to (8) hoarding and slowing down still more the velocity of circulation.
The above eight changes cause (9) complicated disturbances in the rates of interest, in particular, a fall in the nominal, or money, rates and a rise in the real, or commodity, rates of interest.
So, the focus seems to be on "Assuming, as above stated, that this fall of prices is not interfered with by reflation or otherwise ...". And any weakness in corporate profits is not in cards, as it is better to sink the state than give up in fighting the deflation?

The economists at BNP Paribas wrote on USD carry trade and inflation last week, with a summary:
Owing to the risk of succumbing to deflation, the G3 are expected to maintain their super-low interest rate regimes.
The effects of these regimes could spill over into the emerging economies via carry trades shorting the dollar, possibly resulting in a renewed surge in commodity prices in the event that emerging economies overheat.
If a currency like the dollar, the global standard for settlements, is shorted in massive carry trades, the macroeconomic impact would dwarf that of the yen carry trades, as the dollar could plunge and commodity prices could skyrocket.
The US could then go from facing deflation to facing surging prices from imported inflation and, if this were to rekindle problems plaguing the US financial system, the Fed could again be faced with the dilemma of having to choose between stabilising prices or stabilising the financial system.
However, Fed should be praying that they are in control of, especially, food and energy prices (what they usually are not, as they exclude exactly the food and energy inflation from their focus on core inflation). The economists of BNP Paribas wrote in explanation:
There is a risk that, at some stage, the dollar could plunge and commodity prices could skyrocket. At that time, the macroeconomic impact would dwarf that of the yen carry trades. The US could then go from facing deflation to facing inflation due to dollar carry trades swelling to the point of triggering imported inflation. And with this imported inflation eroding real purchasing power in the US, thereby becoming a constraint on the economy, there is a chance that problems plaguing the US financial system could be reignited. The Fed would then be faced with the dilemma of having to choose between stabilising prices or stabilising the financial system. This is one risk scenario currently facing the FX market.
We have short memory? Will we notice the rise in food prices? Car makers, very likely, will...

There is much more of the alike discussion at FT Alphaville...

Bild.de: Knackt der Dax die 6000er-Marke?

There is no reason to be bearish, as Bild.de speculates:
Knackt der Dax die 6000er-Marke?


Who said that tops are usually marked by false breaks?

Bylov: Global Intermarket Perspectives

Jan Bylov, chief analyst at Nordea Markets, is a "rare specie" among analysts, as he is looking himself at all asset classes and uses inter-market approach in analyzing the markets. He writes in the summary today:

Stocks – The power of Goldilocks

Earnings season has begun well while macro economic surprises apparently peaked during September. Now, in absence of a new and stronger macro economic theme why are investors and speculative futures traders responding by buying so heavily? Well, we maintain that the dominating reasoning is found in that fact that most investors have been disbelievers of the recovery and hence underperforming severely! Consequently, with Goldilocks of low bond yields, a weak US dollar providing global liquidity, stable commodity prices, leading stock indices dominated by higher reaction lows and central banks holding back their exit strategies then underweight investors facing year-end are being pressured to allocate more capital towards global equities! The bull market will remain intact until the occurrence of a reaction which exceeds the June setback in both time and size. We are structurally bullish.

Bonds – Walking or talking!

Aside from Australia who recently hiked the official interest rate no leading central bank has yet walked the walk but rather talked the talk, and interestingly Fed’s liquidity operations are still causing investors to load up bills and short duration bonds… no matter the talk of governors! Volatility in treasuries is much bigger influenced by the anecdotal evidence from numerous research reports/opinion makers on an intensifying global debate about the timing and tools necessary to normalise the unusual historic monetary accommodation. A path which also includes a fight between central banks’ independence versus policy makers daring to reduce deficits. For now, leading central banks are talking the talk and postponing their exit strategies as they fear the Japan scenario and the public uproar about the government deficits. Just “talking the talk” should support bond prices and Friday’s selling was probably as much about asset allocation towards equities as it was about Fed talking! We continue expecting prolonged trading ranges in yields, and that the yield direction will oscillate between the popularity of two transient investment themes: 1) “supply fear and exit strategies” and 2) “high real yields and hesitating central bankers”.

Commodities – Precious metals the only real mover

Gold is breaking up from an 18-month range advocating a continuation of its long-term bull market! Now, aside from precious metals global commodity price remain quite stable in all major currencies, and they haven’t been able to produce and maintain new recovery highs since June. This stability should remove a concern to a continued global economic recovery!

Currencies – Central bank divergence

We have revised the overall dominating transient investment themes of the US dollar: 1)“the US dollar collapse theory” (unchanged) and 2) “central bank divergences of the world". Theme 2 has been altered as anecdotal evidence from numerous research reports/opinion makers suggest an intensifying global debate about the timing and tools to normalise the unusual historic monetary accommodation. A path which also includes a fight between central banks’ independence versus policy makers daring to reduce deficits. The global perception of central bank divergences continue to see an escalating and historic extreme short position in USD and GBP! Now, the current Goldilocks scenario continue to favour cyclical risk and rejection of historic valuation considerations as investors remain overwhelmed by the desire for carry and the feel-good factor of momentum! We too hold on to our May -09 carry basket strategy of long BRL, TRY, RUB funded by CHF and CAD, and protective measures should slowly be tightened.

Historic performance of four main asset classes below, click on chart to enlarge, courtesy of Nordea Markets.

Sunday, October 11, 2009

UPDATED: Classic "Text Book Recovery" Of US Housing

While reading the latest "bear warning" on "gigantic error of pessimism" from ECRI, one should have noted that US Weekly Leading Index "was pushed up by strong housing activity".

It just happens that Calculated Risk has compiled some facts and opinions on the policy of supporting house prices. It is definitely worth reading the original post in full. I excerpt here some key messages:

As Representative Frank notes, the policy of the U.S. appears to be to support asset prices at almost any cost. This includes:

- The FHA insuring "bad loans" for buyers with a high probability of default.
- The first-time home buyer tax credit (the FTHB makes no sense from any other economic perspective).
- Delaying foreclosures, first with moratoriums and then with "trial modifications".

We could probably include the Fed buying GSE MBS to lower mortgage rates, and other policies like increasing the "conforming loan" limit to $729,750 in high cost states.

Intentionally encouraging loans with high default rates (insured at taxpayer expense), and the FTHB tax credit (especially allowing buyers to use the credit as a down payment) have stimulated demand. And delaying foreclosures has restricted supply.

Well, there are some other games in play too. First of all, I really appreciate the "earnings recovery" story at banks, some of "organic drivers" are listed by Calculated Risk. However, at the end there comes the sustainability of feeding the corporate profits with taxpayer money, but I will focus on that during next week ...

With this kind of government capitalism I just thought to ask why markets dislike investing in Venezuela?

Obviously, the central belief is that government can control everything, until someone probably recognizes that it cannot (e.g., velocity of money, or on the other side of spectrum - reflation running like the process of unintended panic of currency debasement; just random thoughts)? Or even further out, the current state will be flushed down the closet in the name of corporate profits?

UPDATE: It is worth reading also "A Bounce? Indeed. A Boom? Not Yet" by Robert Shiller at The New York Times. The conclusion at the end is:

WHAT should we conclude? Given the abnormality of the economic environment, the sudden turn in the housing market probably reflects a new home-buyer emphasis on market timing. For years, people have been bulls for the long term. The change has been in their short-term thinking. The latest answers suggest that people think the price slide is over, so there is no longer such a good reason to wait to buy. And so they cause an upward blip in prices.

At the moment, it appears that the extreme ups and downs of the housing market have turned many Americans into housing speculators. Many people are still playing a leverage game, watching various economic indicators as well as the state of federal bailout programs — including the $8,000 first-time home-buyer tax credit that is currently scheduled to expire before Dec. 1 — in an effort to time their home-buying decisions. The sudden turn could signal a new housing boom, but is more likely just a sign of a period of higher short-run price volatility.



Friday, October 09, 2009

SocGen On French Manufacturing, ECRI's Latest Bear Warning

The economists at Societe Generale are wondering about French manufacturing today, click on chart to enlarge, courtesy of Societe Generale.

In the meantime, the ECRI has issued a bear warning:

October 09, 2009 (Reuters) - NEW YORK, - As the U.S. economy rebounds from a long-running recession, a weekly leading index of future growth released on Friday showed the annualized growth rate hitting a record high.

The Economic Cycle Research Institute, a New York-based independent forecasting group, said its Weekly Leading Index rose to 128.3 in the week to Oct. 2 from 127.1 the prior week.

The index's yearly growth rate rose to new all-time high of 26.1 percent in the
latest reading, from a revised 25.0 percent the prior week.

"With WLI (Weekly Leading Index) growth rocketing to a new record high, the economic recovery will prove to be far more resilient in coming months than most believe possible," said Lakshman Achuthan, ECRI's managing director.

"The risk of a double dip (recession) is very low,"Achuthan added.

The index was pushed up by stronger housing activity, he said.

Robert DiClemente, the US economist at Citigroup, added today:
The absence of a strong leading role from consumers does not undermine prospects that recovery will be sustained. Slow and steady improvements in financial markets are closing off risks of a renewed slide.
The supremacy of financial markets and mechanical monetarism will make the trick. Equity bears are punished this week for "gigantic error of pessimism". Just put every bear on government steroids and they will dance!

Thursday, October 08, 2009

Krugman Still Chasing The Shadows

Well, I do not know who is chasing what?
But the chart from BNP Paribas shows quite clearly what is the problem of credit markets! Click on chart to enlarge, courtesy of BNP Paribas.

Reduce debt and/or increase income. Asset reflation is not the same, for most, as income ...

Chinese Credit Festivities

While we celebrate the re-birth of the US consumer, let's look at Chinese winds - what are they blowing? Well, US stock market appears more enthusiastic about materials and energy, less so consumer discretionary titles, at the very moment.

Finally, even the economists at Citigroup Global Markets have noticed the credit boom in China, and are wondering today - How Long Would It Last? First of all, reading the first two paragraphs of summary:

China’s credit growth could decelerate next year, but it’s unlikely to return to “normal” in the near term.

Recently, Chinese officials emphasized the need to maintain a “sustainable level” of credit growth. This could imply around 33% yoy, or Rmb10tn in new loan growth for this year. The unprecedented credit boom lifted the Chinese economy out of its downturn by mainly boosting investment in the state sector.

Interestingly, according to Citi economist, "maintain "sustainable level"" in Chinese means now "unlikely to return to "normal"'.

Further on, the final sentence of summary describes our inevitable destiny:
A continuing credit boom will surely encounter asset price bubbles or CPI inflation, or both in the coming months, in our view.
Obviously, Chinese pig farmers are no fools and know the rules of "asset reflation" even if economic momentum fades. They are hedging the debasement of renminbi by purchase of copper stockpiles? But why are Americans worried about the debasement of US dollar? Well, this is, of course used by smart people (Masters of Mechanical Monetarism) to print the "economic recovery story".

The chart below is supposed to show how stunning growth in credit and money supply in China is hopefully providing the so needed medicine to falling growth of nominal GDP. Click on chart to enlarge, courtesy of Citigroup Global Markets.

As we know, according to Citi' s analysts, the inflation and asset bubbles are our destiny. However, the leading indicator of Shanghai stock exchange is struggling to confirm? Click on chart to enlarge, courtesy of Citigroup Global Markets.

It may be curious, but equity strategists at Nomura were puzzled about the Hong Kong stock exchange yesterday:

In fact, we are puzzled why investors have not questioned more the underperformance of the equity market relative to the build-up in liquidity. Certainly, the underlying strength in the balance of payments has been real and this has forced an easing in domestic monetary conditions. With a rebound in re-exports, ongoing confidence in the Chinese economy and relaxed US monetary policy, in some respects the stock market should have done a lot better. Moreover, it is beginning to underperform the more cyclical economies, such as Korea’s.

Equity’s underwhelming performance relative to changes in the balance of payments is even more stark when compared to previous economic cycles and the recent decline in the greenback. There are a number of reasons. Firstly, real interest rates are still high as deflationary pressures are still passing through the economy. Secondly, the lending cycle remains modest in comparison to previous cycles and household gearing remains low. Thirdly, financial leverage in the equity market is muted in comparison to 2007 as warrant turnover attests. Hence, there has been neither a multiplier from domestic lending or through financial leverage.

Yes, watch that outperforming market of Korea ...
Who knows? Let's party till it lasts ...

Wednesday, October 07, 2009

Deutsche Bank In The Sweet Spot But Upside Remains On The Table

Equity strategists at Deutsche Bank updated their equity baskets yesterday, the description of economic background is "sweet":
DB is optimistic about the economic outlook DB’s economists believe we have now entered the ‘sweet spot’ for the global economy. A slowing rate of inventory reduction, ongoing fiscal stimulus, easing credit conditions and continued loose monetary policy have stimulated a faster than- expected recovery in GDP growth. As a result, over the last six months, both DB and the Street have moved from cutting GDP forecasts to raising them significantly. Despite this swifter growth, however, significant spare capacity means unemployment is still rising (albeit more slowly) and the inflation nemesis remains subdued. Policy action is likely to remain accommodative therefore. DB expects the Federal Reserve to keep rates low until unemployment has clearly turned, so rates should remain unchanged until at least late 2010. In Europe, we expect the ECB to start raising rates in H2 2010.
The current ‘sweet spot’ could persist for six to nine months or longer The sustainability of current conditions remains the unanswered question. It’s likely that by H2 2010, fiscal stimulus and an end to de-stocking will be weaker drivers of yoy growth. By that time, a pick-up in private demand will likely be necessary to drive sustained economic recovery. Visibility remains low on this eventuality. However, if economic data continues to generally surprise on the upside, the likelihood of such a scenario increases. If correct, further upgrades to consensus earnings estimates are likely. We do recognise, however, that there are significant top-down risks. If higher inflation causes central banks to tighten monetary policy sooner than expected or if the recent economic improvement proves to be a false dawn, then a fall in the value of our equity baskets is likely.
Who should care about sustainability, if "the upside remains on table"? Equity buyers prefer "the upside" rather than sustainability concerns?

Well, the strategists at HSBC see the US economic surprise rolling over:
Read the following sentence twice. It is a cardinal error in investing to confuse the cyclical with the secular. Evidence of a cyclical upturn in the developed world shouldn’t be confused with structural health. And there are three signs that the cyclical recovery might be running out of puff.
Click on chart to enlarge, courtesy of HSBC. I would say that J.P.Morgan had a similar call on economy, but remained optimistic on blind bull running ...

Technology freaks should have all eyes open and bet on Windows-7 release, according to equity strategists at Deutsche Bank:
In recent weeks there have been a number of supporting instances of newsflow that further fuels our view that the Windows-7 release will drive a powerful upgrade cycle impacting the software, semis and hardware technology sectors. These data-points have included;
Micron Technology; flagged on 30th September that the “bit content per box” would grow in 2010 riding on the Win-7 release which is particularly encouraging for the memory segment of the semis market. Further, AMD, Broadcom and Marvell flagged order stability which generally reads well for the PC market.
Microsoft flagged in late September that Ford, Continental Airlines, Starwood and Intel have all announced intentions to upgrade to Win-7. Specific details of planned upgrades were not released but this paves the way for the beginning of the corporate upgrade cycle to commence.
Intel in earlier September indicated that corporate PC demand is likely to rise in 2010 driven by an ageing installed base and the release of Windows 7.
Finally, checks by DB US IT hardware analyst Chris Whitmore (“PC cycle to turn” – 22nd September) indicated that Q309 was tracking better than expected. These checks, coupled with the view that macro-recovery in 2010 will help drive PC replacement, encouraged an upgrade to PC expectations for 2010 – from 0% growth to +10% growth year-on-year.
Because Vista is such a disaster? I am also announcing my right to upgrade free of charge, because of mal-investment in Vista!

No wonder that there is an explosion of USD debasement fears, and weaker hands grasping for gold ... to keep the rally alive one needs to expose the "asset reflation", if economic surprise fails? I do not like conspiracy theories!

Tuesday, October 06, 2009

Edwards: Japan Still Leads ...

Albert Edwards, the top ranked strategist at Societe Generale, writes today:
I have long believed that a post-bubble world would play out in a very similar fashion to Japan's lost decade of the 1990s. To be sure there are huge differences, but the similarities are also surprisingly close. Bubbles have a habit of playing out in a certain way.

I remind readers of a few simple key facts that continue to nudge me towards the view
that the Western authorities are set for dismal failure in their attempts to atone for being asleep at the wheel.
and this is key mssage, in my view:
The de-rating of Western equity markets from their New Paradigm highs is still unfinished business. In Japan it took many cycles to fully purge their excess valuation. I have a clear and vivid recollection that at the peak of each mini-cycle, market strategists protested that equities were so very cheap they couldn't possibly de-rate any further; yet they did (see chart below).

However, allow him for:
But let me be humble for just a second. One question I am often asked at the end of a presentation is “how will you know if you are wrong?” Resisting the temptation to totally reject this possibility, I think perhaps I can identify one thing that might indicate this post-bubble world had defied the law of gravity and was reinflating again. Back in the early 1990s minicredit crunch it was not until the middle of 1993 that private sector demand for credit began to grow (supply was not a problem as banks were already healthy). To gauge whether the world economy can surprise and escape this balance sheet recession, keep a very close eye on the bank lending numbers. They may hold the key.
John Hussman also wrote quite interesting commentary yesterday, I would like to point out this one paragraph:
Probably my clearest drawback as an investment manager is that I have too often assumed that investors should recognize what seemed to me to be patently obvious dangers (the predictable collapse of the dot-com bubble, the tech bubble, the housing bubble, the oil and commodities bubble, etc) with a longer lead-time. Unfortunately, we inevitably experience a period of frustration – at least temporarily – for assuming such foresight. Still, none of those has caused trouble for us like they did for the rest of the world. Sustainable long-term returns require the avoidance of major losses, and the best way to avoid major losses is to avoid a) securities where the probable long-term cash flows do not justify the price, and b) markets where the probable returns from accepting risk are unlikely to be durable. There are a lot of investments that can be bought for short-term speculation that fail this test, but advance anyway - until they don't. The most important lesson I keep having to re-learn is how utterly myopic investors can be when there's an uptrend to be played.
There is still an uptrend to be played!

But below 990 for S&P500 one should have a clear picture, why the game ...